PRESS RELEASE – FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE 17 November 2026
Audit & Governance Committee Urged to Launch Independent Probe into £22.3m Watlington Relief Road
Oxfordshire County Council’s Audit and Governance Committee is being urged by community alliance and campaign group Oxfordshire Roads Action Alliance (1) to launch an urgent investigation into the county council’s £22.3 million Watlington Relief Road project. Official records revealed that £14.1 million of corporate funds has been committed with no identified developer recoupment mechanism, no planning permission, and no updated business case since 2021.
ORAA has tried for years to raise these governance, financial, and policy concerns through formal public representations—including at the Oxfordshire Leaders Joint Committee (Oct-25) and Full Council budget meetings (Feb-26) (2) warning that the Council was taking on all the financial risk without a legal mechanism to recoup forward funding and had not assessed low-cost alternatives.
Under Item 20 (Work Programme) of tomorrow’s agenda for its meeting on 18th November, the Audit Committee will consider an unprecedented cross-party referral from the Council’s Performance and Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee (18 September 2026). Budget scrutiny committee councillors referred the project after spending six months asking Cabinet for a proper options appraisal—one that evaluates the scheme against the Council’s Local Transport and Connectivity Plan, including its Policy 36a (3) —only to be sent an unpublished, four-paragraph summary in June 2026 without supporting evidence attached.
The referral asked that the council’s whole capital programme be reviewed to determine whether the failings identified with the WRR project are systemic across other schemes. Tomorrow’s Audit Committee meeting is also considering Agenda Item 6 (2025/26 Audit Results Report) and Agenda Item 10 (Risk Management Update), which highlight significant internal control weaknesses and record Strategic Risk SR22 (Major Infrastructure) at the maximum possible 25/25 High Residual Risk rating.(4)
Watlington Relief Road Key Financial and Governance Concerns for Decision Ahead of Tomorrow’s Meeting:
· £14.1m Corporate Funding with No Recoupment Source: Despite public assurances that the £14.1 million committed from Council reserves in 2025/26 and 2026/27 would be replaced and the council would maximise its capital programme, the money comes from internal capital funding and has no source to replace the expenditure.
· Unverified Capitalised Labour: The WRR has been progressed through three consecutive teams of external consultants, officers and seconded staff. In the 2025/26 Audit Results Report (Agenda Item 6, Page 10), External Auditor EY flagged a control failure on capitalised staff costs, finding that “capitalised labour costs were not supported by appropriate evidence” and that “there was no appropriate evidence that timesheets were reviewed and approved prior to capitalisation.”
· Maximum 25/25 Unmitigated Risk: The Council’s Strategic Risk Register (Agenda Item 10) rates both Major Infrastructure (SR22) and Organisational Capacity at the maximum 25/25 High Residual Risk, with existing controls rated only “Partially Effective.”
· No Cabinet Business Case Since September 2021: Cabinet has not taken a formal executive business-case decision on the scheme since September 2021, when it approved expenditure of £2.893m to complete Stage 2 Design & Procurement. (5) The road was costed at £7.13m–£9.98m and funded by central government Growth Deal grants and S106 contributions with zero Council reserves.
· Education Expansion Land Compromised: Official planning records also raise Best Value concerns over why 2.3 hectares option on school expansion land—already secured for free under earlier outline consents ahead of the May 2028 expiry of temporary classrooms—was re-negotiated by seconded highway officers onto a site severed from the school by a 30mph HGV route.
· Concerns Over Audit Independence: Ahead of tomorrow’s meeting, ORAA has raised that the agenda wording—which proposes letting “relevant officers” work with the Chair to design the review—risks allowing the Highways teams, seconded engineering consultants, and Legal officers involved in the scheme to mark their own homework.
Call for Statutory Independence Under Best Value Rules
ORAA is calling on the Audit and Governance Committee to accept the PCS (budget scrutiny) Committee referral in full tomorrow, while instructing the Council’s Head of Internal Audit and Counter Fraud and Section 151 Officer (supported by external legal advice) to scope the investigation independently.
An ORAA spokesperson said:
“External auditors have already noted unapproved staff timesheets being charged to capital budgets, while the Council’s own risk register notes Major Infrastructure sits at a maximum 25 out of 25 risk rating. Budget scrutiny members asked for an options appraisal for six months and were given just four short paragraphs. Tomorrow, the Audit and Governance Committee must stand up for Oxfordshire taxpayers by ordering a genuinely impartial Internal Audit investigation, independent of the officers, external consultants, and legal teams working on the council’s own project.”
ends
Notes to editor
1. Oxfordshire Roads Action Alliance is a community alliance and campaign group that supports Oxfordshire’s sustainable transport policies. ORAA is a consultee on Oxfordshire County Council’s County Matters planning application for a Watlington Relief Road.
2. Since 2021, the group has consistently raised concerns through formal planning objections, the Oxfordshire Leaders Joint Committee, scrutiny committee interventions, and council speeches
3. Local Transport & Connectivity Plan Policy 36 a. Only consider road capacity schemes after all other options have been explored
4. Agenda, Oxfordshire County Council Audit & Governance Committee, Wednesday, 18th November, 1.00pm
5. Outline Business Case, Watlington Relief Road
